Uh OH! A point of light indicating we might be bottoming? We all know whats coming next.
Fury, anger and denial from the bears who dominate this board. Put on your snark shields now boys!!!
Uh OH! A point of light indicating we might be bottoming? We all know whats coming next.
Fury, anger and denial from the bears who dominate this board. Put on your snark shields now boys!!!
Enzyte FTW!
That chart proves that the homebuilders flatlined oh so long ago, but what a good looking corpse!
Keep 'em coming, boys!
Meeeeeeeeeooooooowwwwww.... *THUMP* ....... *THUMP* ............. *THUMP*
(Sorry to any animal rights activists here, only one cat was harmed for this post and it was about to be put down anyhow.)
Well, isn't it about time for the survivors of the shakeouts to start emerging? I mean: even those going into hibernation mode (ISTR Dawg talking about a VP of a homebuilder who told him that was the sum of their current business plan?), wouldn't they know who they are going to be and who is going to die? It is a horrible number still, but it seems reasonable to think that nearly two years after the credit bubble popped (9/07), we'd be approaching the point where we have some idea where the new equilibrium will be.
The confidence game card continues to be dealt from the bottom of a marked deck.
I don't give a shit what builders think. Dirtbags. Talk about overcapacity.
Perhaps there is a survivor bias here. Is there a component of the index regarding having fewer competitors? I assume if a builder liquidates they stop filling out the surveys.
It's worth noting that the single largest contributor to the increase was in the area of "sales forecasts, next 6 months".
So the homebuilders (those that remain!) are telling us that they expect sales to get better soon. Or ... maybe that they've been down so long that it's started to look like up. Take your pick, I guess.
"I assume if a builder liquidates they stop filling out the surveys. "
Indeed.
I was wondering that myself some investor guy, when the competition goes TU it does tend to make one more "confident"...I wonder if Lehman and Bear made GS more or less confident?
Coming across the wire---
LOS ANGELES (AP) -- The National Association of Home Builders says its housing market index posted its biggest one-month jump in five years in April as many homebuyers seized on lower prices and incentives.
If we could only Build more land....poor souls.
It's worth noting that the single largest contributor to the increase was in the area of "sales forecasts, next 6 months".
So the homebuilders (those that remain!) are telling us that they expect sales to get better soon. Or ... maybe that they've been down so long that it's started to look like up. Take your pick, I guess.
Maybe that will happen while over 600,000 people are losing their jobs every month and a new wave of foreclosures are coming into the market.
Maybe...
I dunno. I monitor my small market via Redfin, California city of 55K, and they added eight homes to the listing just yesterday. Almost all existing, plus one new condo that won't move. We didn't have the land here for huge tracts of new homes.
In short, I'm looking for signs that phantom inventory is about to surface. Let you know if I see a trend.
I bet the Bandoes are smiling and licking their chops. This just means more abandoned homes to squat in.
There is no followup..the builders are just doing the same thing as CNBS...speaking BS
CR - based on your chart, the builder confidence index usually bottoms at the end of a recession.
Does that mean we may get a govt revision later this year saying the recession ended 1Q 2009?
PR on all this is pure BULLSHIT. My town (up and coming) is 50% DOWN from same three months last year for permits on new home and remodeling.
Talking heads on CNBC said that uptick was due to more traffic through model homes, but that hasn't yet translated into increased sales. Since this is a sentiment index, traffic will help - it must be lonely sitting in those empty model homes.
A tradeable data point? Maybe. An indicator of fundamental economic recovery? hahahahahaha
Show me the Sales! Then I will come out of the bear cave.
Ahhhh Spring. Flowers blooming, birds chirping, sun shining, hope bursting all around.
Could be a dead-cat bounce. There was one in Jan. '07.
The housing market index (HMI) increased to 14 in April from 9 in March. The record low was 8 set in January.
Out of 100? What are you measuring that you can tell the difference? I mean, whoa, holy HOMEBUILDER CONFIDENCE INDEX SKYROCKETS! INCREASES BY 50% IN JUST ONE MONTH! I'm sure that's very compatible with the new Global Nice Nice agenda but what do these numbers represent and will this change when the foreclosure moratorium pushes more REO onto the market?
Well, we are told this is nothing but a crisis of confidence, so . . .
With the NAHB members who have gone bankrupt no longer contributing to the survey the survivors are reporting that conditions have recovered to the halcyon days of November 2008.
Since this is a sentiment index
"A point of light indicating we might be bottoming?"
How about the fact that there are a few less, of the worst home builders, left. So, that might affect the sample set. Not that that is not a good thing long term, but would tend to make looking for the "glimmers of hope" like looking for an undigested peanut in a shit sandwich.
Byz,
ding ding ding... we have a winner!
Let's see, the California NODs just hit a new record, F&F shut their foreclosure moratoria down March 31, the major banks likewise...
Here in uptown Charlotte NC. One huge Condo complex could not sell any units so they are now offering them for rent. Granite counter tops, pool, movie theater, etc... for around 1K and the kicker they throw in 2 months free.
4 house on my street for sell for more than 6 months. No one is buying...
Every week I see more and more used homes for sale that nobody wants, but people are buying new homes all of the sudden?
Something smells rotten in the state of Denmark to model.
How could they not like the deal BofA was giving to all Pysicians (at least in CA):
0 to 5 Percent Down plus waiving PMI.
That deal ended in March, so expect the Builders' Blues to return in short order.
Oooh, energyecon, a new marketable debt maturity table. My favorite!
Wow. Wish I hadn't seen it.
"I don't give a shit what builders think. Dirtbags. Talk about overcapacity."
Well, at least at the end of the day, they have produced something, "real." Unlike the bankers and financial engineers.
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Homebuilder-sentiment-index-apf-14934131.html
Check out the above Yahoo! headline of this awful eCONomic report. "Soars" ???? WTF! Total propaganda. Is it any wonder that most Americans have jack didley squat for net worth.
And Obama and Bernanke want to preserve all the fraudulent and fictional wealth. In the end, that will only make the majority of Americans even poorer.
What a sham!
"Zilch said...
Uh OH! A point of light indicating we might be bottoming? We all know whats coming next.
Fury, anger and denial from the bears who dominate this board. Put on your snark shields now boys!!!"
Yep - just like when sales in the bubble zones started to rebound last spring. The attitude of the posters on this blog was pure denial, "nope - cant continue for long - dead cat bounce - etc. etc." 1 year later, everyone accepts it as fact - sales in the bubble zones are up.
Expect to see the same phenomenon now. People will accept that the index rebounded about a year after it has come to pass....
NEW POST at Calculated Risk.
Ways to view:
Dead simple, read only interface at: http://users.thelink.net/bobn/CR
CRC-like interface at http://realize.org/cr/crcizer/
Full Blown Interface at http://www.hoocoodanode.org/
For live chat, and the new Mishbot feature, as well as notice of new posts on other blogs, join us in IRC.
To access IRC with firefox, install the chatzilla add-on and go to irc://irc.realize.org:9996/calculatedrisk.
Or set your IRC client for server irc.realize.org port 9996 and /join #calculatedrisk.
Feed back via bobn
"4 house on my street for sell for more than 6 months. No one is buying..."
Given NC's unemployment picture, I find it hard to picture a jobless new college grad running out and qualifying for a home loan.
Bottoming as in "L" shaped? I have yet to notice capitulation by the 401k'ers around me. They're keeping the faith like fundamentalists.
Arbitrage Macht Frei wrote on Wed, 04/15/2009 - 10:30am.
Every week I see more and more used homes for sale that nobody wants, but people are buying new homes all of the sudden?
Something smells rotten in the state of Denmark to model.
California saw a lot of this in the last two housing busts. Mechanics liens are being settled by giving the subcontractors with claims the houses. Small investor groups, doctors, lawyers, etc. are catching knives. All kinds of "sales" are not really retail or arms length transactions.
I saw this article from the WSJ http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123981347136021633.html and decided to come to CR for some context... Context makes all the difference in how you interpret the article.
The builders I know, all small fry, are surviving on remodeling projects. They build up a 'to do' list among existing clients, and work off the list in downturns. (It may be that some people are remodeling rather than putting the house on the market, that's certainly happening in my neighborhood.) And, yes, there is some schadenfreude among them-- a lot of nogoodniks entered the market during the boom, and are now leaving.
Bottoming as in "L" shaped? I have yet to notice capitulation by the 401k'ers around me. They're keeping the faith like fundamentalists.
Plus the understandable fear of a large taxable event, with penalties.
Here, the government colludes with Wall Street to hold taxpayers' money hostage.
Let's see, what's the ritual again?
Hold hands, shut our eyes and sing Kumbaya?
Seriously though, an uptick from 10% to 15% in the short term puts us back to the builder confidence level from January... I wonder how much of it is: "holy $#!%, I can't believe we are still in business, maybe if it doesn't get much worse we'll survive another quarter".
From the radio this morning: residential construction here is at a standstill, 60K jobs lost, professionals that made $30/hr last year are taking any work they can get for $9/hr. Commercial still hasn't crashed here, but it is slowing fast and shows extreme signs of fatigue. And this is from the state least affected by the slowdown according to some estimates.
Bob Dobbs,
That's what I am looking for, also. I think a few relatively positive news headlines will bring out a flood of new listings of existing homes. My guess is that the months of supply will zoom past last year's.
But we will see.
people buying houses at prices below replacement costs.
at best homebuilders can get some cash (dimes to dollars) out of their standing inventory.
let me know when the confidence index increases to a point where they start buying lumber...
Hurrah !! We can get back to running an economy on just buying and selling each other houses !
Take a look at homebuilder stocks today. They really like this news.
Then take a look at HB stock-price charts going back more than 20 years. You'll have to rub your eyes and make sure you're seeing right. The share prices are ridiculously high, based on hopes of a return to the bubble-level earnings.
I agree with the "confidence game" comments above. I see a blantant attempt to reassure the masses. I see it in statements from the government (Ben, BO, etc...), from the banks (WFC, GS, etc...), and from corporations in general (INTC, homebuilders). It's as if the word went out from the powers-that-be, "Hey, put on a happy face, folks!". "Spin it and make it look good".
As Marlon Bando said in On The Waterfront Condo, "I coulda been a condo renter."
Scone,
Additionally, it's probably easier to find good subs today, and perhaps some of the bad ones have left the field, and even the area.
In regards to you question about the origin of the word slave from some days ago, it was actually coined by the Vikings. They'd ramble through the areas of Eastern Europe and swipe Slavic women they called slavs and sell them to Arabs and others, and these individuals became known as slaves. So there ya' go.....
This sounds so much like Robert Toll's "dancing on the bottom" of a couple years back.
Ways to view comments on this thread:
Dead simple, read only interface at: http://users.thelink.net/bobn/CR
CRC-like interface at http://realize.org/cr/crcizer/
Full Blown Interface at http://www.hoocoodanode.org/
For live chat, join us in IRC.
To access IRC with firefox, install the chatzilla add-on and go to irc://irc.realize.org:9996/calculatedrisk.
Or set your IRC client for server irc.realize.org port 9996 and /join #calculatedrisk.
Feed back via bobn