I don't see the problem. $4 trillion is only like four bills.
Oh, wait, they mean U.S. dollars?
- Nemo
I don't see the problem. $4 trillion is only like four bills.
Oh, wait, they mean U.S. dollars?
- Nemo
The Roubini party girls like big numbers.
George Soros Says "US Banking System Is Effectively Insolvent" (Reuters Video & Transcript)
Go George.
I am in purgatory at the moment. Yesterday, my sharp tongue lit into Sarah Palin. CR commented about asking, politely, everyone to refrain from personal attacks. For my comment about Sarah Palin, some lobbyi$t called me a "leftie," so I let him have it. Can I come back? If not, I can cut a deal, down here, with the devil, so I may come back as the beast, 666. You have been warned
By the way, Sarah Palin is a public figure, so cannot be considered exempt from attack. Is the new commenting system going to allow diverse views?
Would you be surprised to learn that literally nobody cares what you think about Sarah Palin?
- Nemo
Somebody mentioned me?
Only 4 trillion.. optimists!
was it not 2 Trillion of losses on Sunday?
Bucky gonna save the day?
What is a couple of trillion between friends?
How much did WW2 cost.. adjusted for inflation?
So the IMF says toxic assets will continue to grow and will reach $4 Trillion.
Meredith Whitney says we are going to see a directional change and the banks are returning to profitability.
One of them has got to be wrong
$4 trillion is about $500 per person on the planet.
How could that result from giving loans to poor people in the United States?
"Would you be surprised to learn that literally nobody cares what you think about Sarah Palin?"
Yeah, I guess you're right. No one seems to care what I think about finance/economics either. But I read and post links to relevant articles -- I try to stay on-topic, anyway -- so if push comes to shove the site may miss a link contributor. Some people have enjoyed the links I've posted. Just sayin' ... maybe I should start a new blog. I could "scrape" CR's blog, along with the stuff I find, and it might be the bestest. But I am aware of the blogger's curse ... must continually supply new content, otherwise the readers don't come back.
No doubt this guesstimate of "where it could spiral" is really where things have already gone.
Kudos to all those involved in fixing the commentariat input software. Excellent job!!!
The CR/Roubini/Shiller/etc. of the next phase is going to be the first (and loudest) one to ring the 'Depression' gong.
Who is it going to be?
When asked how they could be off by $1.8T, an IMF spokeshole said:
"Whoops! These numbers are really big and stuff. And, well, we use several models, and Europeans use commas where periods go and vice versa...confusing really. Then Timmah and the boys come over and pull the models out and run around with them playing WWII dog fight and drop them and all..."
Nostrovia,
I predict Krugman will bang the gong first.
Lucifer wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 9:26pm.
What is a couple of trillion between friends?
How much did WW2 cost.. adjusted for inflation?
I don't about money but it wasn't cheap in lives. The demographic effects are still rolling down the European generations
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Or maybe Simon Johnson.
So Rounini is an optimist now correct?
Then we are so f#cked.
Only 4 trillion.. optimists!
I saw the headline and thought: So what, it's all just numbers anyway. Now If they had said two years ago that there might be horrendous losses of hundreds of billions, then I might cut them some slack. But throw around trillion dollar figures now and you've got to believe it's almost meaningless, i.e., there's no way this is going to equal "real money", we're in the realm of imaginary funny money.
Everyone is a doomer now.
Stocks should rally.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
RFFMC
How much did WW2 cost.. adjusted for inflation?
about $4 trillion
http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2008/11/big-bailouts-bigger-bucks/
Sarah Palin? Didn't she used to be somebody?
At the rate we are going we could soon have more dollars in derivatives than there are stars in our universe..
Big difference between financial and political commentary (and links). One of them is almost always on-topic here. The other is almost always not.
Not trying to silence you; just trying to change the subject.
- Nemo
Isn't Sarah a J-People name? She must be part of the bildaburgers.
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
"How much did WW2 cost.. adjusted for inflation?"
There was a graphic, over at Barry Ritholtz's site, within the last several months that compared the big U.S. expenditures, in inflation adjusted terms, agains the current bailout. It even went back to the things like the Lousiana purchase, Alaska purchase, Marshall Plan, etc.
The Milky Way's has about 200 to 400 billion stars... most of them are too faint to be seen from over a few light years... red and orange dwarfs.
The Milky Way is estimated to contain between 200 to 400 billion stars... most of them are however too faint to be seen from over a few light years... red and orange dwarfs.
And the stock market jumps up at the least whiff of good news. This thing is far from over. It'll be over when really good news has NO effect on the stockmarket. Complete and utter depression and apathy. Long into the future.
The Japanese finance minister on Monday pledged to unveil a new $100bn (£678m) package aimed at boosting employment and helping the stricken economy through its deepening recession.
Meanwhile Spain lengthed the time allowed for naps...
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Nemo,
Robert Reich counts. Has he called a depression?
Anonymous wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 9:43pm.
Nemo,
Robert Reich counts. Has he called a depression?
Well, he admitted to using Zoloft
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Damnit Nemo, Stroke the lizard! Don't go Reptar! I will miss your shiny little eyes
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
"Toxic debts could reach $4 trillion, IMF to warn"
Enough about T-bills! What about the other debts ?
"Meanwhile Spain lengthed the time allowed for naps... .."
I always liked your sense of humor, nova.......
- - - - -
Black
Ranch
Reich called it on his blog, as well as taking swipes at both Geithner and Summers.
Nemo,
Dang. Reich called it. What do you think Nemo?
BSR,
Thank you. And I enjoy your agricultural extension classes...mooooooo!
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
What's the big deal? Just have the central banks of each country buy the debt, and then have the IMF buy that debt. Problem solved.
"Robert Reich counts."
Just not very well. Poor guy, practices all the time too. I understand he can get to 20 all on his own now....
Nostrovia,
I just realized women can count higher than men...
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Anonymous:
Yes, Reich called it a depression the other day.
Nice to read you again, Misean. Still hangin' onto your gold or have you sold it for Shamwows?
homedad43
BSR, Are goats that finicky when comes to giving milk?
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
how i can disagree with George Soros so much on polotics yet , repsect his financial thoughts. I have held fast that Citi and BOA are together 4 trillion insolvent,,,, personally i think globally they are off a magnitude IMHO
So now the IMF is concerned...Whats in it for them...?
I want to see a krugman graph that depicts how you can lose all the jobs created since 2001 while having stagnating to declining real wages and maintain the $4Trillion in nominal GDP growth?
FiveFiveFive CanIHaveFive IGotFive SixSixSix DoIHearSix SixOverthere EightEight IHaveEight NineNineNine.................WHERE'S MY WHISKEY? I like a nice little Blowup as much as anybody,but this is starting to get out of hand.I will not live in a world where I have to wipe my ass with leaves or corncobs!
I'll stand up for reptillian. I think I saw the original Palin comments; less obnoxious than some of the other stuff I've read here. Having said that, a Palin-free zone is my first choice, but whatever.
Barley,
".Whats in it for them...? "
A brand new, shiny, super ultra fast printing press, and the only set of keys to the control room.
Nostrovia,
How much did WW2 cost.. adjusted for inflation?
about $4 trillion
And to beat a drum you've all heard (well, most of you), WW2 was followed by a large number of young men returning home to work, while the competitors were recovering from the destruction. Fortunately now we've got lots of older folks who will retire soon and boost our economy by spending the massive savings they've carefully set aside, right? Right? RIGHT?
"George Soros Says "US Banking System Is Effectively Insolvent"
Fact is he still is living in the USA and most likely keeps a US bank account...
nough said
the recovery started 3 days and 2 hours ago..
good luck on the "other side"
Interesting Times,
the IMF will revise upwards after the fact.
$14tn in US residential mortgage debt, more than half will be on negative equity properties, REO sales tend to recover 80% of market price after fees.
Now consider what made the mortgages so sellable was the structures which used leverage.
Those are all facts we all knew last September
Yet people still don't understand the banks are not being nationalized & cleaned up because of fundamental limitations. There was an option to cut them loose and overnight create a barebones financial structure to offer savings, checking (sic), wire transfer, lines of credit, and other basic banking functions. You already have thousands of post office locations, you would have your pick of people to hire, you could buy software from failing(-ed) banks, the government already offers a range of lending (mortgages, student loans, small business, export, etc). could through anti-trust get into the credit/debit card game
but that would have been a loss of face, a big task to ask of small people, and perhaps soured foreign investors on the entire market (I'm trying to think of the best arguments against, give them the benefit of the doubt)
hoard, guns, money, food and freedom wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 9:56pm.
the recovery started 3 days and 2 hours ago..
good luck on the "other side"
Finally get hired for the night shift at 7-11?
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Misean - The IMF are control freaks...more disasters make then work to foster their interests. A manufactured form of supremecy.
nova - Still selling cigs to minors?
barley , i think GSoros would mean the bigger 5 or 6... community banks OK as far as reserves go... it would be nice to see who all the reserves have gone tyo though.... jeez UNC seems to own MSU....
Barley (member) wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 9:59pm.
nova - Still selling cigs to minors?
And fortified wine. For you, I have a case of white whine.
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Goats are a pain in the ass from what Jeff (a neighbor) says. They don't give up much milk and they are totally misbehaving miscreants - but I really don't know, I can't see the sense in wrestling around a BIG dog size animal that's only looking to knock you on your ass for a quart's worth of milk. No thanks, I like cows.
.......it's like Christmas morning here! The Mrs. worked her last shift today (from her REAL job). I feel like a wiggly-puppy-dog - well, maybe "parts" of me do......it's going to be nice working with her again.
- - - - -
Black
Ranch
"I will not live in a world where I have to wipe my ass with leaves or corncobs! "
Don't worry about it. When the food runs out, production ceases and no wiping needed. :-(*)
Alaska should stop letting Malamutes and Huskies vote. They're cute with those blue eyes, but they don't think long term strategically like most humans.
EHP - "but that would have been a loss of face"
Bingo. Greatest and costliest cognitive dissonance ever.
BSR, I like goat cheese and I figured they are about the size of my dog. Then again everytime I try to give her a bath - she wins.
http://afterthecrash.net - Home of the Doomer Story Portal and Other Stuff
Barley,
"The IMF are control freaks..."
Are positions are fundementally in agreement.
Nostrovia,
nova - tanks! I'll trade u some dired beans, pickled okra, and jerky.
Let's sell California to China. From LA south, let's sell it to Mexico. That should take care of our financial mess. Uncle Sam can then get a deal from Mexico so we can keep operating San Diego Naval base while in Mexico territory.....just as we do in Guantanamo.....for free.
Ohiio, Indiana, and Michigan can join Canada, and enjoy free health care. Unemployment rate should get lower as soon as those 3 state leave the union.
Washington state is sold to India, and then might as well buy British Columbia. Bill Gates becomes an honorary Indian citizen.
Florida is let go....we have not have it for many years now anyway. Or better yet, we can sell it to Cubans living in America.
New England states can join Quebec-Canada or Greenland or Iceland...whetever suits them better.
Rush Limbaugh can buy Texas and show us how to run a country. Lou Dobbs will be his Secretary of State! and G.W.Bush Treasury Secretary of the Republic of Texas!!!
Whatever is left of the former USA should then be on the right financial track to become a good European country!
Who said we can not fix this financial mess? Sell, sell, sell, sell....and problems solved.
Some music to blog by
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ouI5KcyHfE
100 days and 100 nights
Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings...
"Yet people still don't understand the banks are not being nationalized & cleaned up because of fundamental limitations."
Yeah, our rulers don't want to go teets up...
Nostrovia,
This is all a lead up to 12/21/2012 - the Mayan prediction for the end of the world. Don't worry, be happy. Just make sure your balloon amounts are after that date.
I got all warm and fuzzy reading this. Crocuses everywhere! From the NYTimes:
They are only losses to the lenders. To the borrowers, it's $4 trillion in debt relief.
I don't mean this in a small snarky way. I mean this is a big multinational, cross-generational, between classes kinda way.
The amount of people and stuff in the world hasn't changed much. The people who had lots of paper (called stocks, bonds, mortgages, and deeds) thought it was worth more than it really was. The people who planned on very short horizons (or not at all) haven't lost much money, because they never saved or invested much.
A movie about this would be called Revenge of the Innumerate Slackers.
Lucifer wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 5:38pm.
The Milky Way is estimated to contain between 200 to 400 billion stars...
Aren't you neglecting the super massive AIG sitting at the core? You may not see it, but you can detect its gravitational effects on the rest of the galaxy.
I've been out of pocket myself, are you guys telling me the same blog that previously tolerated commentor 'Elvis' is now censoring 'reptilian' for bashing Sarah Palin?
I mean, that's soooooooo 2008, but really.
I remember back a couple of years ago $7 trillion was the magic number to get us out this mess. Has that gone up?
Only $4T? Hell, the Treasury and Fed have already spent or committed to spending that already. In addition there are $8T or so nebulous guarantees, going on that widely used $12T number floating about.
Can someone begin to explain this?
"We've come a long way. I remember when"
CR
I remember when my neighbor threw a spoon of potatoe salad in July 07. He was aiming for me 'cause I was yacking about the approaching peril. He was a RE agent.
Well, now we see something has changed. He and his wife was over for dinner the other weekend. Their 401k is down 54% and this month (April) they are going to let the foreclosure happen on their house. He has not sold a property in seven months and she is now working partime, from full time...btw they have 30% skin in the game...but simply cant go on. I said nothing. I served a geat BBQ dinner.
whatever happened to our "elvis"?
NorkaWest
sdtf,
that would be a black hole not some exploding budding universe creation.... come on watch direct TV 278 before dirty jobs.....
What's 4 trillion in the scheme of things? The current market rally has about 3 months shelf life until reality again imposes it's will. try to remember last years August-October drama and I expect we will see the same thing again (rewind and press play) only this time the stupid pet tricks of the FED/Treasury are used up.
Shnaps: Funny you should mention that; I thought anonymous @ 7:01 sounded just like Elvis.
MikeinLongIsland: Good find on Sharon Jones. Might have to hit "replay" a few times.
barley,
that is so hilarious...in 2006 a guy who is now one of my best friends was coaching my 6 yr olds machine pitch baseball team.... he was a broker (mortgage) i asked if he sees the pending bursting bubble, he looks at me and says DC area is immune but doesnt see one nationally anyway.... then i start spouting terms no one had ever heard of like exotic mortgages, etc. and he asked if i was in the industry, i said kind of...he looks at me as we are picking up balls, and say "we are so fu'kd" no new home loans in 4 -5 months...baby on the way...so mods i am hoping for, i even tried to talk my mom into refing to get him some business....
i smoke a mean butt myself.....
"Can someone begin to explain this?"
----------
Hmmm.
Someone is lying?
IMF economists are behind the curve, again.
In the U.S., alone, following the trajectory of writeoffs that we had in the Lesser Depression, writeoffs of household debt, alone, will be $6 trillion.
Beyond that is U.S. corporate and government debt, and the junk from Spain, Britain, Eastern Europe, etc.
$4 trillion is just a warm up, IMF.
"I am in purgatory at the moment. Yesterday, my sharp tongue lit into Sarah Palin."
Which thread?
AIG is just a medium sized black hole.. The financial-legislative complex is the real deal.
Blackhalo,
"Yesterday, my sharp tongue lit into Sarah Palin."
Which thread? "
I'm sure you can get that in streaming video by now...
Nostrovia,
It's not too late to declare sovereign bankruptcy, in concert with ordering principal write-downs on private debt
jus' sayin'
i defer to you Carl Sagan i mean uhhhhh Lucifer....
A request for CR.
When you publish the graph of employment losses from peak for this current and previous recessions, could you please note that the birth/death model was phased in starting June 2000. Even the BLS notes that an ARIMA estimation is faulty during turning points. Since the point of the graph is to look at turning points in the economy, it seems like an important change.
As always, thanks.
I am doomed.
Bernanke = Michigan State
Deflationary Debt Monster = North Carolina
I don't recall seeing this posted before:
"Economy Rescue: Adding up the dollars". Here are all the elements of all the bailouts."
TOTAL: $10.5 trillion allocated, $2.6 trillion spent
http://money.cnn.com/news/specials/storysupplement/bailout_scorecard/ind...
- - - - -
Black
Ranch
reptillian's ghost,
It could be worse.. you could be Ben Bernanke
"I am doomed."
reptillian,,
Yes, you're doomed.. .so are the rest of us. Don't go anywhere...you would be missed.
EHP:
"I pissed away all my money, believe it or not."
Nice clip. And sums the whole thing in ten words.
"I chased away anybody who loved me."
And that's the last eight years.
Very nice clip.
Evelyn Woods: and what if Michigan State pulls it out?
Well, it could happen...
homedad43
So the IMF says toxic assets will continue to grow and will reach $4 Trillion.
Meredith Whitney says we are going to see a directional change and the banks are returning to profitability.
One of them has got to be wrong
Whitney said short term bounce for the banks is possible. Longer term she didn't have much hope.
BSR,
CNN is underestimating the amount by 2-4 trillion..
MISEAN, SHNAPS... so good to see you again.
Looks like the new comment system is bringing everyone back. Thanks yet again to Master Ken!!!
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
BSR,
"TOTAL: $10.5 trillion allocated, $2.6 trillion spent"
Getting to watch it all go POOF! before it rips your face off.....Priceless.
Nostrovia,
listening to a Geithner peice on NPR today, i was incapacitated with laughter after hearing this gem:
If you discriminate against borrowers or prey on vulnerable homeowners with fraudulent mortgage schemes, we will find you, and we will punish you
i wonder if he means ALL of the mortgage fraudsters...
UCE
Evelyn Woods: and what if Michigan State pulls it out?
Well, it could happen...
homedad43
2nd half recovery?
More Reasons to Worry About Inflation
Many deflationistas believe that the wealth being destroyed by the bursting of the global credit bubble will swamp the money being created by fiscal and monetary authorities for the foreseeable future, thus eliminating the threat of inflation, at least in the near term.
But what they seem to be discounting is the effect that a contagious loss of confidence can have on the value of a fiat currency, which is, after all, dependent on the continued faith of those who accept it as a medium of exchange and a store of value.
If, for example, enough people start to believe that a government is embarking on road-to-ruin economic policies, hordes of those who hold the currency may suddenly start stampeding for the exits, altering the supply-and-demand equation and leading to a contraction in its purchasing power.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
Evelyn Woods:
Sure, why not? And the market is up another 500 points...
G'night folks.
homedad43
I don't recall seeing this posted before:
"Economy Rescue: Adding up the dollars". Here are all the elements of all the bailouts."
TOTAL: $10.5 trillion allocated, $2.6 trillion spent
I have been saying that the cost to pay off every US mortgage is 10T.
Why couldn't we have done that in the 1st place?
Sorry I missed the Whitney thread earlier, but does anyone really doubt that another 30% drop is in the cards?
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
"we will find you,"
Has Timmah been playing golf with OJ?
Nostrovia,
"It just keeps getting worse ..."
Well put, CR. Well put.
If, for example, enough people start to believe that a government is embarking on road-to-ruin economic policies, hordes of those who hold the currency may suddenly start stampeding for the exits, altering the supply-and-demand equation and leading to a contraction in its purchasing power.
When I read this, it seemed that every third word, started with an "O" and ended with an "L."
I wonder if the economy is MSU or UNC? Not too hard to figure that out.
TJ,
" hordes of those who hold the currency may suddenly start stampeding for the exits,"
Thing is they don't have currency....they have stuff, denominated in currency....and the price of THAT stuff is declining...
Nostrovia,
THE OLD joke is that there are 10 sorts of people ; those that understand binary code and those that don't. Some markets are binary too, in the sense that they either function brilliantly or not at all.
http://kstp.com/news/stories/S866307.shtml?cat=1
Apartment vacancies are up and rents are down here in the Twin Cities as well. Not news to you all, just confirmation.
BSR,
"TOTAL: $10.5 trillion allocated, $2.6 trillion spent"
Getting to watch it all go POOF! before it rips your face off.....Priceless.
Here is the link to watch it http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7UPU8nP_p0
I suspect this Russian bomb was actually made in China and was tested near St.Petersburg, FL
That stuff going up in flames was US pension funds
But patientrenter says the private sector "does more with less".
Evidently 4 trillion more.
Misean,
As you well know most of our hard currency is held by foreigners. They could stampede us into inflation all by themselves.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
Nice to see (waving) the old guard's back.
Who cares what Nemo says. He's just a wannabe writer. No content. Just fluff. Ignore him.
Reptillian- stick around, you've been a regular long enough to earn forgiveness from the rest.
Nemo- lighten up.
On topic- The IMF needs to treat us like the banana republic we are and shake a shake a the truth stick and then hit us up side the head with it like they have all the other bad children they've taken into foster care. Seriously. We can't fix it ourselves. Let some adults take a shot.
TJ,
"As you well know most of our hard currency is held by foreigners."
Yeah, that's a bit of a problem.
Nostrovia,
TJ - thx, but in my case it was more lack of internetz, although I do like Ken's latest killer app. Although it is painfully slow on the ipod. Maybe some enterprising nerd can whip up an iphone app for comments? That's so hot right now. The most popular article in todays NYT featured some neoMaxiZoondweebie who made his million by writing a shoot-em-up app for the iPhone. (Yay, America.)
Misean welcome back.
OT: for a searing Italian realist look at failure of law enforcement check out "Gomorrah", about the Camorra in Naples.
This is not your father's Hollywood Mafia.
Yep, we are all screwd,
but we can make a list, start trials and seizures.
Hmmm... how about (not in any particular order):
Greenspan
Paulson
Bernanke
Mozilo
Kazkarian
All AIG, JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Wamu and Bear Stearns employees
All CNBC employees (starting with Jim Cramer, Larry Kudlow and Maria Bartibobo)
Maximum penalty for treason is of course, death.
This report and that nice Nigerian email demanding money made my day. Thanks.
Outsider,
$10 trillion is quaint. As of 2008 Q4, outstanding mortgage debt in the US was $14.4754 trillion (Federal Reserve Flow of Funds, Z.1 / L.2 / line 10, http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/Current/z1r-4.pdf)
and there is $27.6752 trillion in domestic debt in the US after you remove
• mortgage, $14,475.4 bn (L.2, line 10)
• federal government, $6,361.5 (L.1, line 7)
• state and local, $2,239.6 (L.1, line 
• (I subtracted rest of world, L.1 line 9 if you are trying to follow along)
For perspective, 2008 Q4 nominal GDP in the US was $14.2003 trillion (BEA, http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/gdpnewsrelease.htm) but that is falling much more and much faster than was prepared for
Well, the tsunami just washed over my small town in Flyover Country.
One of the largest employers is shutting down. Friends, neighbors & one of my relatives will lose their jobs. A shop on Main St. is closing too.
Good paying jobs with bennies are hard to find in this rural county. Hospital/care center is a large employer...they're losing about $3,000/mo now. Cutback on hours & layoffs should be next. The state's been bleeding manufacturing jobs for a long time now. Hundred jobs here, 300 there, devastating to a small community. And pretty soon you have no manufacturing left.
Wake up folks.
The latest "total" is maybe 10% of the real problem. The strategy is deny, delay and loot as much as possible from the US Treasury before Joe Sixpack wakes up and screams bloody murder.
And the problem with the bailouts is way beyond "moral hazard" and deep into criminal fraud territory. Its to be expected when the original fraudsters are left with full access to the controls instead of facing perp walks or at least the bum's rush to the curb. Retention bonuses my a$$.
Does any one really believe the $3 Trillion expansion of the Fed balance sheet is temporary? Or that the parade of multi-hundred billion dollar bailouts is over? Similar bailouts (funded by quantitative easing) will soon become quarterly, they will increase in size, and their main impact will be to turn deflation into inflation. This has been the only viable (?) plan since August 2007.
It will end badly.
Hint: the Chinese leadership is not as clueless as Joe Sixpack.
I recall a blog thread re "I wonder how our friends in Europe view the American bailouts". A European responder noted that "All your friends seem to be bankrupt, but you have many new adversaries".
Enjoy.
Damn, just read the formatting options link. This
could come in handy on Friday nights...
"Apartment vacancies are up and rents are down here in the Twin Cities as well. Not news to you all, just confirmation. "
In Phoenix, I know of one apartment complex -- recently built as condos, went rental when the buyers disappeared -- that has reduced its rents about 25%!!!!
Sorry I missed the Whitney thread earlier, but does anyone really doubt that another 30% drop is in the cards?
Uh, Jim Cramer?
MLM,
LOL, I meant here, of course. Anyone resident on CNBS by definition doesn't have a clue.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
But.. but but,,, Bernanke said the total cost of the credit losses would be $100 billion.
Somebody isn't a wewy good foecasta.
EHP,
"$10 trillion is quaint."
"quaint: b: pleasingly or strikingly old-fashioned or unfamiliar"
So, to use in a sentence:
It's quaint how that maingy, old, rabbid squirrel has fastened its teeth onto your nut sac....
Nostrovia,
(I do realize the $2,570bn in Farm and Commercial mortgages aren't what we are talking about, but debt is debt)
longtimers - pl help me work through this. I don't understand the 4T number.
Given that money has neither been created or destroyed:
If the banks lost money, that means that somebody else won - the homeowners who sold during the bubble, the employees in the FIRE industry etc
Net Net, things are still in equilibrium and you would expect the winners to be taking up the slack at this point.
But, that is not happening - Any simple explanations to help me understand?
Misean,
Such is the luxury when you have a pitbull chomping away on top of that squirrel
fiat currency: thought we'd see how many people we could cram in the damn thing
Given that money has neither been created or destroyed
Siwwy Wabbit.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
Bernanke said the total cost of the credit losses would be $100 billion.
Obviously the forecasts couldn't be contained.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
anony @ 8:19: we need Morgan to force all the bastards in a room to take responsibiity
fat chance with this crowd
EHP,
;P
Anon,
"But, that is not happening - Any simple explanations to help me understand? "
Lever broke.
Nostrovia,
But, that is not happening - Any simple explanations to help me understand?
An impaired balance sheet causes the bank's to hoard cash in anticipation of future losses; this hoarding drives the money multiplier (1/reserve requirement) to zero.
Instant money destruction.
OT but interesting:
Communities print their own currency to keep cash flowing
http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/2009-04-05-scrip_N.htm?loc=interst...
A small but growing number of cash-strapped communities are printing their own money.
Borrowing from a Depression-era idea, they are aiming to help consumers make ends meet and support struggling local businesses.
The systems generally work like this: Businesses and individuals form a network to print currency. Shoppers buy it at a discount - say, 95 cents for $1 value - and spend the full value at stores that accept the currency.
Money was destroyed. Or, it was illusory to start with.
By the trillions.
Hilarious, almost (saw this at Zero Hedge):
March Federal receipts are 30% below '08.
https://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/100xx/doc10069/04-2009-MBR.pdf
Obama, you are in a hole.
Quit digging.
alybaba,
"Communities print their own currency to keep cash flowing"
Similar ideas have been around for a while...
"The Barter Business Exchange (BBE) will refer new customers to your company. The new customers we send will pay for your products and services with barter dollars which you can use with any other participating business in the Barter Business Exchange. The barter dollars earned from these customers can be used to eliminate your current cash expenses. We currently have over 600 participating businesses."
http://www.ncbarter.com/howbbeworks.html
Nostrovia,
six trillion gone
Obama, get some of your South Side of Chicago Fruit of Islam neighbors to have a nice terse 'chat' with Timmy, Ben, and Larry.
Those three do not listen to reason. Maybe they will listen to force.
Afterwards, they can become the new Three Stooges (Ben has to shave first, of course).
"Shoppers buy it at a discount - say, 95 cents for $1 value - and spend the full value at stores that accept the currency. "
I thought the Fed/Treasury/IRS frowned on such behavior. Seems like it would be a pain on the tax forms.
95 cents means the banks issuing the scrip expect more than 5% inflation or dollar devaluation when the merchants redeem it.
Obama, you are in a hole.
Quit digging.
Or simply start printing. The only reason the government collects taxes under fiat regime is to control inflation. Since inflation is not the primary concern now, the government can simply print however much it needs. Tax receipts are just nostalgia for the times when money was based on gold.
Anonymous @ 8:19pm
2 ways notional money is destroyed
You can think of these 2 cases as:
- My house is my retirement plan, then finding out it is not worth what I expected
- A company that has value up until it defaults, and then it goes bankrupt where creditors find out the company had more debt than assets.
CR, if a shortfall of 30% for Federal tax receipts does not scream ''Depression,' I have no idea what does.
Fiscal year to date through March, Federal receipts are down 14%.
Wow.
Down hard and accelerating.
March Federal receipts are 30% below '08.
At the state level, some interesting trends: People are declaring the maximum exemptions. People filed for their refunds ASAP, increasing the Jan-Mar deficits. But the thing that's gonna suck is that there's not going to be a pot of capital gains tax gold on April 15 (except for the shorters).
yeah, yeah
What Misean (lever broke) or what yogi said (either destroyed or never existed in the first place, up to personal preference)
MrM, take a look at 10 year and 30 year rates; nice increase these last few days.
Falling receipts do matter. Deficits do matter.
Just ask the Chinese, who keep placing threatening phone calls to Ben and Timmy.
From reading the comments here and on the last thread, I'm thinking maybe I misinterpreted what Meredith Whitney said. I thought she meant accounting gimmickry would allow the banks to claim a short run increase in the value of their assets and decrease in their liabilities even though this was just papering over their true situation, they remain screwed, and will be earning next to nothing in the future. Please correct where I misunderstood on this.
EHP,
No, no....I enjoy watching you go the long way around. I'm just too busy eating and watching Top Gear to type it.

Nostrovia,
"Hint: the Chinese leadership is not as clueless as Joe Sixpack."
Apparently so, as they seem to have accumulated themselves into an uncomfortable position. If they attempt to liquidate their dollars or even stop buying them, they destroy their export economy AND the 2 trillion in dollar based assets they hold.
China, welcome to capitalism, you noobs.
The federal receipts data can still be a little noisy in March - those with refunds are filing early and those with liabilities are filing later. However, I still expect horrific numbers by the end of it all.
Could one of you regulars please explain why or how the "Comrade" titles came about? Is it a joke about the future direction of the country or are you members of some grand movement? I'm wondering whether or not to join in...
MrM, take a look at 10 year and 30 year rates; nice increase these last few days.
I know, I know - I keep watching it all the time. The long bond yield is at 3.73% and is going to go much higher.
I've said it many times: there are just two solutions to the current mess (not mutually exclusive) - inflate and default.
Of course we will try hard to inflate, and most likely will try to avoid defaulting.
Please correct where I misunderstood on this.
They will be earning nothing, not next to nothing.
minor error
lawn grass wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 8:28pm.
$4 trillion is about $500 per person on the planet.
How could that result from giving loans to poor people in the United States?
:::::
Leverage.
Don't forget
3. Giant Alphabet Ponzis: CDS, synthetic CDO squared, ABS, in the shadow balance sheets.
"Any simple explanations to help me understand?" @Anon
Any simple explanations to help me understand?
Money as debt:
The tale of the goldsmith was the important part to me. The rest was, meh...
yogi,
"3. Giant Alphabet Ponzis: CDS, synthetic CDO squared, ABS, in the shadow balance sheets. "
You've been reading Lovecraft again, haven't you?
Nostrovia,
"It just keeps getting worse."
Yes, but finally we are getting to the real numbers!
The total disappearance of illusory housing wealth I guessed a year ago to eventual be up to $8 trillion.
It makes sense to see a number like $4T in losses, since various institutions should suffer some large fraction of this kind of number on their various exposures to many forms of debt, say more than 20% and less than 80% of this kind of number.
We are getting in range.
""Communities print their own currency to keep cash flowing""
a) no one will trust any individual community when it comes to currency
b) any printing of cash that is not supported by any real goods leads to high inflation
c) high inflation (we are talking double digits) spells two huge problems: destruction of any positive sentiment & impossibility to do any long term business planning. it is not just contra productive, uncontrolled inflation is the most destructive force in the economic universe
comrades simply want to be in on the ground floor as the economy sinks into a swamp.
we are holding hands and hoping the mortgage pig keeps it's snout in the air so we all breath as the sucker goes down.
"The federal receipts data can still be a little noisy in March"
The unemployed withhold very little... BLS, they put the L, in BS.
coupla argentinian guys I know are going to give a demo on bartering, who's in? there's money to be made...... well maybe not money, but stuff, there's stuff to be made. gonna take off I tell ya.....
Protests are planned in cities across the country on April 11
http://www.anewwayforward.org/demonstrations/
Good night all
Anonymous wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 8:48pm.
Could one of you regulars please explain why or how the "Comrade" titles came about? Is it a joke about the future direction of the country or are you members of some grand movement? I'm wondering whether or not to join in...
Both. Stil, feel free to join in. It's all just serious fun on this blog, until the coming apocalypse. Then we start meeting in the fallout shelter.
p.s. comrade mesian, welcome back!
(must be a tax season )
uncontrolled inflation is the most destructive force in the economic universe
on par with uncontrollable deflation - money has to be a reasonably stable store of value 
Good night (again)
Flashback:
Should you, or any of your Impossible Missions Force be caught or killed, the Secretary will disavow any knowledge of your activity. This tape will self destruct in ten seconds.
"how the "Comrade" titles came about?"
simple, all of those bailouts is a step from market capitalism to connection ridden social capitalism, hence a title like comrade might or might not deliver certain benefits.
[Kresa, who described this weekend's meeting as "extensive," is working to replace a majority of GM's board before an August annual meeting as part of the changes the U.S. government wants.]
The deck chairs on the sun deck need to be tilted a little to take better advantage of the sun's rays as the band strikes up another tune. All the life boats have been deployed...
Comrade came in when Bush's man Paulson started socializing losses in hundreds of billions.
We holdouts are still waiting for socialized gains.
CR, those tax receipt numbers are going to be really interesting the next year or two. How about a few graphs now and again?
[comrade canadien avec popcorn wrote on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 8:58pm.
coupla argentinian guys I know are going to give a demo on bartering, who's in? there's money to be made...... well maybe not money, but stuff, there's stuff to be made. gonna take off I tell ya]
Ha ! I an quite confident there's already quite a brisk black/barter market in existence in canada, what, with the GST, PST, SST... and all the other Mista Ts. Sheesh.
CdC,
"(must be a tax season ) "
Yes, and it's less fun than being Daffy Duck in Wabbit Season.
Nostrovia,
yogi,
3 is included in the first 2 points, for your examples
Either a bank made a loan to them so they could lever up and valued it too highly
Or they sliced + diced so well that none of the value was set aside for a contingency (the equity tranche will never be touched, easy 5%), which is included as a side note in point 1 and only modifies the severity of the losses
Those 2 ways in the previous post are the only way I know of to 'destroy' money as it were, short of actually physically burning it.
Now correlation hedged CDO^2s were a problem, but they could not have destroyed money without acting through the 2 primary mechanisms
If I'm overlooking something, I want to set things straight in my cluttered head, but I don't think I have. For there to be money destruction, there has to be an asset/liability mismatch on someone's books. Under the fractional reserve lending scenario, the assets are over-valued. Under the company scenario, the liabilities were greater than the assets. Every financial entity has a balance sheet, and the only 2 ways to destroy money is by creating a mismatch on the balance sheet by either overstating assets or understating liabilities. Same goes for creating money, but in reverse. Printing/removing money merely changes the unit of measure which is usually fixed in contracts
Mr.M.
I shall be at the NYC protest just to see - as a resident of interesting times, I feel it would be a shame if I didn't go just to check it out.
Those 2 ways in the previous post are the only way I know of to 'destroy' money as it were, short of actually physically burning it.
Physical hoarding would also "destroy" (at least temporarily) the money supply.
Waaaaaay OT....back to Imelda Marcos momentarily...but apparently there's test track film of GM's upcoming models.
http://vd.reborn.ru/?a=watch&id=19129
Nostrovia,
"Every financial entity has a balance sheet, and the only 2 ways to destroy money is by creating a mismatch on the balance sheet by either overstating assets or understating liabilities."
Those 2 ways being default on debt, or savings? Japan was having fun with the latter, and we are having fun with the former?
Why not just stick to the topic at hand. Unless of course you don't understand the topic at hand.
"4-13-09: WFC and GS 1st quarter earnings release. 4-16-09: JPM 1st quarter earnings release. 4-17-09: C 1st quarter earnings release. 4-20-09: BAC 1st .."
11 more days to the moment of truth?
EHP,
"by creating a mismatch on the balance sheet by either overstating assets or understating liabilities."
I hedged both through AIG swaps...I'm good.
Nostrovia,
"11 more days to the moment of truth?"
There will be some "moment," but I question the level of truth to be had. Unless you mean by "moment of truth," we get to find out if they will tell the truth, or not.
Thanks for the explanations, Comrades. I've been lurking for a year or two in idle puzzlement. Anyone know if the registration email is meant to be instantaneous?
Money was not destroyed. Dang. Words have specific meaning. Use them properly. Asset of lenders were recognized as being worth-less.
Unfortunately I had to drop my "Comrade" when I became an HCN member, and just when Central Planning is hitting its stride, too.
I mean, hoocoodanode that Obama would be firing CEO's and directing what cars would be made.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
misean...great to read your comments again
mt
"4-13-09: WFC and GS 1st quarter earnings release...
didn't GS as IB report off quarter prior to change to BHC? Nov 28 end of FY
Will the extra month just disappear?
OK, just call 3. fraud in the context of 1. and 2. It's so large that it's almost another category. If the % risk of default and the 10% fractional reserves in your 1. and 2. were honestly applied, we might not be in a crisis.
ok so the lead on this story is
IMF warns of 4 trillion in losses
and i remember when people derided roubini for predicting over 1 trillion
please put me down right now for minimum of 10 trillion of losses
ill take the over if you take the under
mt
Anyone know if the registration email is meant to be instantaneous?
It is damned fast!
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
I've been waiting for a juicy bit like this all day.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Learn the 7TH Amendment maggot!
Red Beckman - Fully Informed Jury
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7385583011526915030&hl=en
Merriam-Webster, "money":
"2 a: wealth reckoned in terms of money"
Money was destroyed. Criticize properly.
"Collateral Damage" would be correct terminology as well, I think.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Learn the 7TH Amendment maggot!
Red Beckman - Fully Informed Jury
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7385583011526915030&hl=en
Burning c-notes is mere destruction of currency, with no effect on net wealth.
It just keeps getting worse ...
Disagree CR. It's been this bad all along. The extent of the damage is becoming increasingly apparent but it's not "happening" now. The "bad stuff" happened years ago when the credit was extended, and in the maladministration of the response to the credit panic.
Could one of you regulars please explain why or how the "Comrade" titles came about?
We celebrate that our nation is now run with the same alacrity and skill that characterized the Soviet Union.
Basel-
"1/RR= $ multiplier"
Didn't Fed banks have their reserve reqs cut to zero last Fall? What kind of potential multiplier does one get with an imaginary number?
Gosh, this is just so entertaining, no wonder I keep coming back!
Good paying jobs with bennies are hard to find in this rural county. Hospital/care center is a large employer...they're losing about $3,000/mo now. Cutback on hours & layoffs should be next. The state's been bleeding manufacturing jobs for a long time now. Hundred jobs here, 300 there, devastating to a small community. And pretty soon you have no manufacturing left.
:::::
Good thing we are a services economy now else we'd be in trouble...
From an email a buddy sent over the weekend... [edited to protect identities]:
.
From what I heard the W-I Auction was a blood bath for the bank. ##person## from ##company## said he didn't think the total auction exceed 1,000,000. 3 year old 2 pallet horizontals that sell for $250,000 went for $10,000 The new die casting machines went for 10-20,000 Everything older was scrapped.
EHP:
"I pissed away all my money, believe it or not."
I heard this version somewhere:
"I spent most of my money on women and booze. The rest I wasted."
Didn't Fed banks have their reserve reqs cut to zero last Fall? What kind of potential multiplier does one get with an imaginary number?
Dunno, but the boys at AIG can probably tell ya.
"
Didn't Fed banks have their reserve reqs cut to zero last Fall? What kind of potential multiplier does one get with an imaginary number?
Dunno, but the boys at AIG can probably tell ya."
I think it's more of a FASB thing....
Nostrovia,
I do not think we have to worry until Obama starts mobilizing the military for parades down Pennsylvania Avenue. When I see the mobile missile launchers on display it will be time to panic.
Disagree CR. It's been this bad all along.
Byz, that's what I've been saying here for ages. To paraphrase myself... "The chances of a depression were always 100%, only people's awareness of it is rising"."
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
If the banks lost money, that means that somebody else won - the homeowners who sold during the bubble, the employees in the FIRE industry etc
Net Net, things are still in equilibrium and you would expect the winners to be taking up the slack at this point.
But, that is not happening - Any simple explanations to help me understand?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking
Start here.
Some money was used to build useless factories in China.
Some money was used to build useless houses in America.
Bets with high leverage can produce losses far larger than the wager.
If you bet with leverage on the profitability of loans to buy useless houses as if there was no such thing as a bad RE investment, imagine how much money you could lose.
hong konger,
Problem is, even without any reserve requirements they do not have enough free cash to generate a positive asset bubble because the existing headwind from the great credit bubble unwind is something that even central banks are incapable of filling at this point. Central banks in essence have the ultimate nominally unbounded balance sheet
nominally unbounded
I like that.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
EHP-
You're correct, of course. I was trying to make to make a funny re: the vanilla money multiplier model.
(1/0= an imaginary money multiplier)
Eh
FWIW...Re: GS 10-K
On December 15, 2008, the Board of Directors of Group Inc. (Board) approved a change in our fiscal year-end from the last Friday of November to the last Friday of December. The change is effective for our 2009 fiscal year. The firm's 2009 fiscal year began December 27, 2008 and will end December 25, 2009, resulting in a one-month transition period that began November 29, 2008 and ended December 26, 2008.
"...a one-month transition period..." ?????????
We are currently working with the Federal Reserve Board to put in place the appropriate reporting and compliance mechanisms and methodologies to allow reporting of the Basel I capital ratios as of the end of March 2009.
Should be OK. Can't be any worse than C. Move along.
Eh, I'll be over here blending in with the wall again...
for the record, I don't think fractional reserve banking is a bad thing. I think the regulation/operation of the system been terrible.
We need to tranche the financial system such that there are discrete elements. The most essential levels must have the least risk.
Investors get to invest with full disclosure of all fees/reward/overhead (plain english, big font, $x and y bps), tie together risk/reward for every investor/trader. No return for no risk. No interest for chequing and savings accounts, but they get the safest regulations. Let other depositors explicitly elect to make their funds available to a checklist of investments (interest rate swaps, CDOs, auto loans, whatever) over locked-in time periods. The products will then have an incentive to become simpler/transparent to attract more funds. System should be able to operate by consciously accepting risk/reward at the individual level, rather than purporting to regulate/insure at the macro view of the conglomerate entity.
It's easier to analyze cement by looking at what you put into it, than by looking at the surfaces of the finished product. Let the regulator set up a fair game, and let participants worry about themselves. That's all we can ask for. No more, no less; lagom.
Lagom
Regarding plummeting federal receipts -- something even my dog predicted -- I fail to see how corporations that aren't making any money are supposed to pay taxes. This isn't exactly rocket science.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
Eh, I'll be over here blending in with the wall again...
Hong Konger,
Go check out Jim the Realtor's second to last post on "Interior Decorating", watch the video, and see if you can blend in with that last wall.
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
for the record, I don't think fractional reserve banking is a bad thing. I think the regulation/operation of the system been terrible.
I'm not a gold bug. =)
Just wanted to introduce the whole velocitiy of circulation thing.
hong konger,
I don't mean to discourage you from commenting, just my way of engaging. Besides 1/0 would be approaching positive infinity- and it is possible to create an infinite amount of money with the mechanism, but the problem is that the risk exposure will rise exponentially as the amount of money created will increase at best linearly with no RR or with decreasing returns if RR between 0 and 100%- e^jπ/2 would be an imaginary number. Perhaps I should develop that into a financial manifesto, imaginary assets (what you trust someone to pay you in future) and real assets (those you can lay claim to today), apparent money being the absolute value of the real and imaginary components. Those with any kind of electrical background probably see the parallel I'm trying to extend.
" for the record, I don't think fractional reserve banking is a bad thing. I think the regulation/operation of the system been terrible.
I'm not a gold bug. =) "
I do and am. Gold, or any hard money needs no regulation, no system set up by and run by the infinitely corruptible.
"Besides 1/0 would be approaching positive infinity"
Depends on the limit...could be defined as approaching zero. Depends on the curve. That's the problem really.
"Those with any kind of electrical background probably see the parallel I'm trying to extend. "
i do believe i do.
But i'm not real until i'm squared.
Nostrovia,
any kind of electrical background
Do super-colander tin foil hats qualify?
-----
"Hope for the best, prepare for the worst"
Because we want to use words properly, 1/0 is "undefined".
The square root of -1 is "imaginary".
yogi
The format I used is more flexible but means the same
Didn't even realized I skipped a step, but thanks
Byzantine_Ruins on Mon, 04/06/2009 - 9:48pm.
Start here.
Some money was used to build useless factories in China.
Some money was used to build useless houses in America.
No money was destroyed. The Debt/Shareholders lost but the construction crew who constructed the house won. The landowner who sold the land won.
EHP - Thanks for your explanation. I am still thinking through it.
Case 1: A construction crew is paid $100,000 to build a house. The house sells for $100,00, and the owners live there for 50 years. When they die, the house is bulldozed.
Case 2: A construction crew is paid $100,000 to build a house, which sells for $200,000. The mortgage is defaulted immediately, the house is foreclosed on, sits empty and rots for 5 years, then is bulldozed.
In case 2 money has been destroyed relative to case 1, trust me. (Even if bulldozing after 5 years makes economic sense at the time)
*taking a small huff from the Fed's bottle of nitrous*
BAH !! This is utter rubbish, these LEGACY assets are worth 98 cents on the $. The losses will be insignificant !
*starting to worry the huff is fading and reality strats to seep through.................*
"The underlying fundamentals of the company are sound. The company is stronger than ever."
Ken Lay. Enron CEO
September, 2001
(BK December, 2001)
No money was destroyed. The Debt/Shareholders lost but the construction crew who constructed the house won. The landowner who sold the land won.
It can be that way if you say so! I'm not going to have an argument about "what is money". I'll just note, it didn't generate an income stream.
National mood is far too ugly to allow a TARP 2.0 to cover $4 trillion in losses.
It'll have to be done backdoor, or else borne by the debtholders themselves.
They're just trying to get the girls who go to Roubini's parties.
- Nemo